Our Menu


Andys frozen custard concretes

Concretes

Andy’s Custom Concrete

The topping of your choice blended with vanilla custard. Create your own unique recipe. A treat to eat with a spoon!

Butter Pecan Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with butterscotch & roasted pecans.

Choc-O-Rocko

Fresh chocolate custard blended with roasted almonds and gooey marshmallow creme.

Snowmonster

Fresh vanilla custard blended with fresh strawberries & melted chocolate chip.

Mint Chip Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with mint and melted chocolate chip.

The Jackhammer

We take your favorite concrete and fill the center with the topping of your choice.

James Brownie Funky Jackhammer

Vanilla custard blended with creamy peanut butter and brownies then filled with hot fudge. It’s GOOD!


Andys Frozen Custard Floats

MALTS AND MORE

Malts

Andy’s Frozen Custard® blended with your favorite topping and malt powder.

Shakes

Fresh vanilla custard blended with your favorite topping.

Old-Fashioned Freezes

Vanilla custard and your favorite soda blended together.

Old-Fashioned Sodas

Cherry, chocolate, raspberry, strawberry, or key lime flavor served with seltzer and fresh vanilla custard.

Floats

Your favorite soda with scoops of fresh vanilla custard.

Italian Ice

Zarlengo’s lemon, strawberry, or raspberry lemonade flavor Italian ice tube.

Andy’s Frozen Custard® Bar

Vanilla custard dipped in milk chocolate.


Andys Frozen Custard Sundaes

SUNDAES

Andy’s Custom Sundae

Fresh Andy’s Frozen Custard® covered with your favorite topping and a cherry. Just the way you like it!

The Original Straw-Ana

Fresh custard covered with fresh strawberry halves and sliced bananas.

Andy’s Ozark Turtle

Fresh custard covered with hot fudge, creme caramel, roasted pecans, and cherries.

Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans

Fresh custard smothered with delicious hot fudge, roasted pecans, and cherries.

Stolen Brownie Sundae

Grandma’s warm homemade brownie covered with fresh custard and topped with hot fudge,
roasted pecans, and cherries.

Andy’s™ Super Sundae

Fresh custard covered with your favorite topping, roasted pecans, and cherries. IT’S BIG!


Andys Frozen Custard Cups and Cones

CUPS AND CONES

Your choice of fresh Chocolate or Vanilla Andy’s Frozen Custard®. It’s Made Fresh Hourly!

No toppings on cups or cones.


Andys Frozen Custard Splits

SPLITS

Andy’s® Banana Split

A whole banana and fresh Andy’s Frozen Custard® covered with fresh strawberry halves, marshmallow creme, then topped with crushed mixed nuts and cherries.

Turtle Split

A whole banana and fresh Andy’s Frozen Custard® covered with hot fudge, creme caramel, roasted pecans, and cherries.


Andys Frozen Custard Toppings

TOPPINGS

Andy’s basic sundaes, concretes, shakes & malts include one topping. For an extra special treat, add more toppings for an additional cost.

  • Almonds
  • Banana
  • Butterfinger
  • Butterscotch
  • Cheesecake
  • Maraschino Cherries
  • Chocolate Syrup
  • Coconut
  • Cookie Dough
  • Creme Caramel
  • Crushed Nuts
  • Heath Bar
  • Hot Fudge
  • M&M
  • Marshmallow
  • Oreo
  • Peanut Butter
  • Peanut Butter Cups
  • Peanuts
  • Pineapple
  • Pretzels
  • Raspberries
  • Reese’s Pieces
  • Strawberries
  • Roasted Pecans
  • Espresso*
  • Key Lime Syrup*
  • Melted Chocolate Chip*
  • Mint Syrup*
  • Stolen Brownie Chunks*
*Not available on Sundaes

 


ccmenuopt

SEASONAL TREATS

Cookie Casanova Sundae *In Season

Chocolate chip cookie with vanilla custard topped with creme caramel, roasted almonds, and cherries.

Thin Mint Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with thin mint cookies.

Blueberry Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with fresh blueberries.                        

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

Shortcake and vanilla custard topped with strawberries.

Blackberry Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with fresh blackberries.

Peach Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with fresh peaches.

Key Lime Pie Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with a slice of key lime pie.

Pumpkin Pie Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with fresh baked pumpkin pie.

Pumpkin Pie Take Home Quart

Vanilla custard blended with pumpkin pie. Frozen daily!

Apple Pie Sundae

A slice of apple pie topped with vanilla custard and drizzled with creme caramel.

Apple Pie Concrete

Vanilla custard blended with apple pie.

Andy Nog Shake 

Vanilla custard and egg nog blended into a shake.

Candy Cane Concrete 

Vanilla or chocolate custard blended with peppermint candy cane pieces.

Candy Cane Take Home Pint 

Vanilla or chocolate custard blended with peppermint candy cane pieces. Frozen daily!

Peppermint Crunch Bar

The bar itself is a great blend of a peppermint flavored Andy’s vanilla frozen custard and Zarlengo’s dark chocolate! It really is a phenomenal treat.


Andys Frozen Custard Take Home

TAKE HOME

Pint and Quart Favorite Flavors

Vanilla or Chocolate

Specialty Pint Flavors

Hot Fudge Brownie
Bordeaux Cherry Chip
Butter Pecan
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Mint Chocolate Chip

Frozen Custard Bars

Vanilla custard covered with milk chocolate
Mint custard covered with dark chocolate
Caramel salted custard covered with milk chocolate
Chocolate custard covered with dark chocolate
Coffee custard covered with dark chocolate

Andy’s Frozen Custard® Gift Cards

Purchase an Andy’s Frozen Custard® gift card for the gift amount you choose. Minimum $5.00 value.

Andy’s 6oz. Chocolate or Vanilla Mini Cups

Two dozen minimum order. Please order in advance. Other flavors available. Call store for details.


Andys Frozen Custard Drinks

DRINKS

Old-Fashioned Sprecher Soda

Brewed in Milwaukee! Root Beer or Cream Soda on Tap

Bottled Sprecher Soda

Root Beer, Cream Soda, Orange Dream, or Ginger Ale

Soft Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, or Orange

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Fresh Brewed Sweet Tea
Fresh Brewed Raspberry Iced Tea
Bottled Water